Category III Alternative Investment Funds (AIFs) occupy a peculiar position in India's tax architecture. While they enjoy **pass-through taxation** (no entity-level tax under Section 115UB), investors don't get a tax-free ride. The fund itself pays no tax on gains; the burden shifts entirely to unit holders. But here's where it gets sharp: investors still face a **surcharge on short-term capital gains** and must navigate detailed **Schedule CYLA reporting**. Most investors and advisors miss these layers.

## What Section 115UB Pass-Through Taxation Actually Means

Section 115UB (inserted via Finance Act 2021, applicable from FY 2021-22 onwards) exempts **Category III AIFs** from tax on income earned by the fund itself. This is a blanket exemption--no tax on capital gains, interest, dividends, or other income at the fund level.

But "pass-through" does **not** mean investors pay no tax. It means:

- The **AIF entity itself pays zero tax** on its income.
- **Each investor is taxed individually** on their share of gains, whether distributed or reinvested.
- The fund must identify each investor's share of gains and report it.

This is fundamentally different from a standard mutual fund (which pays tax at slab rates and distributes after-tax units) or a partnership firm (where partners are taxed on share of income).

## The STCG Surcharge Trap

Here's where many investors get blind-sided: even though the AIF itself pays no tax, **investors still pay surcharge on short-term capital gains** if their total income exceeds Rs.1 crore.

- **Short-term capital gains (STCG)** from an AIF unit are taxed as **ordinary income** at slab rates.
- If an investor's total income (including STCG) exceeds Rs.1 crore, a **25% surcharge** applies on the tax computed on such gains (Section 2(42CA) read with Section 112A).
- **Long-term capital gains (LTCG)** from AIF units held **>24 months** are taxed at **20% + surcharge (if applicable) + cess**.

Example: An HNI with Rs.2 crore annual income realizes Rs.50 lakh STCG from an AIF. That Rs.50 lakh is taxed at their slab rate (say 30%, if in highest bracket), plus 25% surcharge on the tax. Effective rate: ~37.5% just on the STCG.

Compare this to **long-term mutual fund gains** (held >1 year), which are taxed at flat **20% + surcharge + cess** -- often more favorable for long-holding investors.

## Schedule CYLA: The Investor-Level Reporting Requirement

Under the **Income Tax Rules, 1962** (specifically Schedule CYLA, inserted to track AIF investments), **every investor in a Category III AIF must report**:

1. **Name and PAN of the AIF**.
2. **Units held during the year**: opening balance, additions, disposals, closing balance.
3. **Share of income/gains** attributed by the AIF:
   - Short-term capital gains.
   - Long-term capital gains.
   - Other income (if any).
4. **Distributions received** (whether as dividends or return of capital).
5. **Any losses** claimed by the AIF.

This information is furnished by the **AIF to the investor** (typically in the annual account statement or a separate schedule) and must be **entered in the investor's ITR**.

### Non-Compliance Risk

If an investor fails to report Schedule CYLA:
- The income is not automatically ignored by the tax officer.
- A discrepancy notice can still be issued under Section 143(1)(a).
- Penalties under Section 271(1)(c) (up to Rs.10,000 for non-filing) or Section 206(1H) (for non-[TDS compliance](https://www.harunraaj.com/services/tds-compliance)) may apply.

## How Income Is Attributed Under Section 115UB

The AIF is required to compute income (gains/losses) and attribute each investor's proportional share, **whether distributed or not**. The method:

- The **fund calculates total STCG and LTCG** for the financial year.
- Each **unit holder's share is calculated** based on their holding period and quantum.
- This attributed income is **taxable to the investor immediately**, even if not received as cash.

If you held units for part of the year, your share is apportioned. If the AIF realizes a loss, investors can claim their share of that loss (subject to loss-utilization rules).

## Key Planning Considerations

**Holding Period Strategy**: Aim for **24-month+ holding** to convert STCG to LTCG. A 3-month difference in exit timing can swing the effective tax rate by 10-15 percentage points for HNIs.

**Surcharge Planning**: HNIs with marginal income near Rs.1 crore should model whether realizing AIF gains pushes them into the surcharge bracket. A Rs.20 lakh gain might cost Rs.10 lakh more in tax if it triggers the surcharge.

**Loss Utilization**: If an AIF realizes losses, investors can claim them against other capital gains (not ordinary income). This is valuable for portfolio hedging.

**NRI Considerations**: NRIs investing in Category III AIFs are taxed on Indian gains as if they were residents (Section 115UB applies). However, they must file ITR-2 and report Schedule CYLA if they have any residential status tie during that year.

## The Reporting Burden on AIFs

AIFs must issue **detailed investor statements** within 30 days of year-end, breaking down each investor's share of STCG, LTCG, and other income. Many newer AIFs still lag on this--a significant compliance risk for investors who receive partial or incorrect data.

As an investor, **verify your Schedule CYLA data** against the AIF statement before filing your ITR. Mismatches invite tax officer scrutiny.

---

I'm CA Harun Raaj, Visakhapatnam. If you're investing in Category III AIFs or advising on them, let's discuss your tax strategy and reporting compliance.

---

## See Also

- [AIF Annual Compliance: Form N, Form N-2, SEBI Audit & CA Certificate Requirements](https://www.harunraaj.com/blog/aif-annual-compliance-form-n-sat-n-2-sebi-regulations-audit)
- [PPM and LPA Drafting for AIFs: SEBI Mandatory Disclosures, Co-Investment Rights, and the Key-Man Clause](https://www.harunraaj.com/blog/aif-ppm-lpa-drafting-sebi-mandatory-disclosures-co-investment-key-man)
- [Gift City IFSCA AIF: Setup, LRS Investment by Residents, and Tax Neutrality Under Section 10(4D)](https://www.harunraaj.com/blog/gift-city-ifsca-aif-setup-lrs-investment-section-10-4d)

Canonical: https://www.harunraaj.com/blog/aif-taxation-india-section-115ub-stcg-surcharge-cyla