# ESOP/RSU and Wrong ITR: Salary Perquisite + CG Forces ITR-2 and Schedule FA Checks

**Short answer:** If you received ESOPs or RSUs, **ITR-1 (Sahaj) is always wrong** — it has no capital-gains schedule and no Schedule FA. The minimum correct form is **ITR-2**, which carries: **Schedule S** (salary incl. the perquisite from Form 16), **Schedule CG** (capital gain at sale, with cost = FMV at vest under **s.49(2AA)**), **Schedule FA** (foreign shares, if the employer is foreign), **Schedule TR** (foreign tax credit from the 1042-S/withholding), and a separately-filed **Form 67** (before the ITR due date). The most common error: reporting the **full sale price** as the capital gain without deducting the FMV cost basis — which double-taxes you.

---

## Why ITR-1 is out

ITR-1 is restricted to salary, one house property, and other sources up to specified limits — with **no Schedule CG and no Schedule FA**. Once you have:

- A capital gain on sold ESOP/RSU shares; or
- A foreign asset to disclose (foreign employer's shares, a US brokerage account);

…you are outside ITR-1. Filing it anyway invites a **s.139(9) defective-return notice** and the 15-day refiling drill.

## The ITR-2 checklist

| # | Schedule | What goes in | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | **Schedule S** | Salary including the RSU/ESOP perquisite | Form 16 Part B |
| 2 | **Schedule CG** | Capital gain at sale — cost = **FMV at vest** (s.49(2AA)) | Vest statement + sale contract note |
| 3 | **Schedule FA** | Foreign shares / brokerage account (for foreign employers) | Broker & grant statements |
| 4 | **Schedule TR** | Foreign tax credit for US withholding | 1042-S / withholding proof |
| 5 | **Form 67** | Filed separately on the portal — **before** the ITR due date | Rule 128 |

If you have business income (F&O, consultancy), the form escalates to **ITR-3** — which includes all of the above schedules plus Schedule BP.

## Worked example: Kabir's RSU year

**Persona:** Kabir, salaried, FY 2025-26. RSU vest perquisite **₹4,00,000** (Form 16 Part B). He sold shares mid-year: sale **₹6,00,000**, cost basis (FMV at vest) **₹4,00,000** → capital gain **₹2,00,000**. He holds remaining vested shares worth ₹3,00,000 in a US brokerage. US tax withheld on the vest: **₹60,000** (1042-S).

**What he files — ITR-2:**
- **Schedule S:** salary ₹16,00,000 + perquisite ₹4,00,000 = ₹20,00,000.
- **Schedule CG:** gain ₹2,00,000 (sale ₹6,00,000 − cost ₹4,00,000 under s.49(2AA)), short-term or long-term per holding period.
- **Schedule FA:** the US brokerage account and the vested shares held (peak value during the year).
- **Schedule TR:** foreign income ₹4,00,000, foreign tax ₹60,000, credit claimed.
- **Form 67:** filed on the portal **before** the ITR — without it, the ₹60,000 credit is lost.

**The error he avoided:** if he had shown Schedule CG with cost = ₹0, the gain would have been ₹6,00,000 instead of ₹2,00,000 — taxing the ₹4,00,000 perquisite a second time.

**The NRI nuance:** if Kabir sold shares while resident in India and later became a non-resident, special rules on exit taxation and Schedule FA apply — residency on the date of each event matters.

---

## Already filed ITR-1? The defective-return path

If you filed ITR-1 and the CPC later flags it under s.139(9) for missing capital-gains or foreign-asset schedules, do not panic — the notice is a fix-it flag, not a penalty. The drill:

1. **Confirm the defect** — the intimation cites the missing schedules (Schedule CG, Schedule FA);
2. **Prepare the correct return** — ITR-2 (or ITR-3 if you have business income) with the perquisite in Schedule S, the gain in Schedule CG, and foreign assets in Schedule FA;
3. **File the corrected return within 15 days** — the response window under s.139(9);
4. **Respond to the notice** on the portal with the new acknowledgment number.

If you ignore the notice, the return is treated as **never filed** — refunds are blocked, loss carry-forward under s.80 is forfeited, and a s.234F fee can apply. Fifteen days is short but workable when the numbers are already on hand.

## Documents to gather before filing

- **Form 16 Part B** — the perquisite and salary figure for Schedule S;
- **Vest statement + sale contract note** — FMV at vest and sale price for Schedule CG;
- **Brokerage statement / grant portal** — foreign shares and peak balances for Schedule FA;
- **1042-S and W-8BEN** — US withholding for Schedule TR / Form 67.

Assemble these before opening the ITR utility; the form moves faster and the numbers stay internally consistent.

## The headline error, restated

The single most common filing error is not the form — it is the **cost basis**. Report the sale gain as **sale price − FMV at vest**, never the full sale price, and never ₹0. Get that one number right and the rest of the return — form, schedules, foreign assets — follows the same disciplined path.

## Frequently Asked Questions

### 1. Which ITR form do I use if I have ESOP/RSU income?

**ITR-2** at minimum (salary + capital gains + Schedule FA). If you also have business income, use **ITR-3**. ITR-1 is always wrong.

### 2. What is the cost basis to enter in Schedule CG for RSUs?

The **FMV at vest** under **s.49(2AA)** — not ₹0 and not the grant price. Entering ₹0 double-taxes the perquisite.

### 3. Do I need Schedule FA for a foreign employer's RSUs?

**Yes**, if you are an ROR holding foreign shares or a foreign brokerage account. Disclose at peak value; non-disclosure risks a ₹10 lakh penalty per asset per year (Black Money Act s.43).

### 4. What is Form 67 and when do I file it?

Form 67 claims the **foreign tax credit** (Rule 128) and must be filed electronically **on or before the ITR due date**. Late filing forfeits the credit.

### 5. I sold RSUs and now I'm an NRI. Which rules apply?

Special rules apply to non-residents on the sale of shares acquired as a resident, including possible exit-tax provisions and Schedule FA requirements. — the treatment depends on your residency on each event date.

### 6. What happens if I file ITR-1 with ESOP/RSU income?

The return is **defective under s.139(9)** — the CPC flags the missing capital-gains and foreign-asset schedules. You get 15 days to refile in ITR-2/ITR-3; ignore it and the return is treated as never filed.

---

## File the right form with the right cost basis

Before you submit, run your ESOP/RSU details through the **[Defective Return Validator](/tools/defective-return-validator)** to confirm the form and schedules, and the **[ESOP Tax Calculator](/tools/esop-tax-calculator)** to compute the s.49(2AA) cost basis and the real capital gain.

---

**Last verified: 2026-08-08.**  
Sources: Sections 17(2)(vi), 45, 48, 49(2AA), 90, 139(9) ITA 1961; Income-tax Rules, 1962 (Rules 12, 128); ITR-2/ITR-3 schedules; Black Money Act 2015 (s.43).  
Reviewer: pending CA sign-off. Draft status — do not publish before CA review.: NRI sale of shares acquired as a resident.

---

## See Also

- [Unvested RSU on Schedule FA: Reportable or Not? Peak Balance Rule for Indian Residents](https://www.harunraaj.com/blog/unvested-rsu-schedule-fa-peak-balance)
- [US Tech RSU for Indian Residents: RBI FX Rate, Schedule FA and Form 67 Foreign Tax Credit](https://www.harunraaj.com/blog/us-tech-rsu-rbi-fx-schedule-fa-form-67)
- [ESOP Perquisite Calculation: Exercise Price, FMV and Form 12BA / Form 16 Mapping](https://www.harunraaj.com/blog/esop-perquisite-calculation-exercise-fmv-form-16)

Canonical: https://www.harunraaj.com/blog/esop-rsu-wrong-itr-form