# Foreign Withholding on RSU (1042-S) and India DTAA Credit: What Goes in Schedule TR

**Short answer:** When a US employer vests RSUs, it (or its broker) may withhold US tax on the value and report it on **IRS Form 1042-S** — the default NRA withholding is **30%**, reducible to a treaty rate for Indian residents. In the Indian ITR, you (1) declare the vest value as **salary/perquisite**, (2) claim a **foreign tax credit (FTC)** in **Schedule TR** under **s.90 ITA 1961** and **Form 67** (Rule 128), and (3) take the credit limited to the **lower of the Indian tax or the foreign tax** attributable to that income. Form 67 must be filed **on or before** the ITR due date — filing it late forfeits the credit.

---

## What the 1042-S tells you

| Item | What it means |
|---|---|
| Form 1042-S | IRS form reporting US-source income paid to a foreign (non-resident alien) person and tax withheld |
| Box 2 | The gross income amount (vest value in USD) |
| Tax withheld | 30% default, or the treaty rate if a valid W-8BEN was on file |
| Your use | Proof of foreign tax paid — the basis for the Indian FTC |

If no tax was withheld (a common outcome when a valid W-8BEN claims the India-US DTAA), there is no credit to claim — but the income is still taxable in India.

## How the credit is computed

**FTC = lower of (foreign tax paid on the income, Indian tax attributable to the same income).**

- **Foreign tax** = the US federal tax withheld and reported on 1042-S, converted to INR. State tax is generally not creditable.
- **Indian tax attributable** = Indian tax on total income × (foreign income ÷ total income) — a proportionate share.

## Worked example: Rohan's 1042-S credit

**Persona:** Rohan, Indian resident, 100 RSUs vest on 10 September 2025. FMV at vest **$40**; FX ₹84 → perquisite **₹3,36,000**. The broker's system treated the vest as a dividend-equivalent and withheld **15% under DTAA Article 10** (portfolio dividends) = $600 = **₹50,400**, reported on Form 1042-S. Rohan's slab rate is 30%. **This is a broker mismatch, not a correct treaty position** — RSU vest is employment income under **DTAA Article 15**, where India has the exclusive taxing right on a resident employee's income earned for services rendered in India, so the correct US withholding on the vest is **nil**. The mismatch means Rohan's real remedy is an IRS refund / 1042-S correction. The example below assumes an Indian AO accepts the withheld amount as a Rule 128 credit only after Rohan documents the mismatch — verify with the CA before claiming.

**Step 1 — Declare the perquisite:** ₹3,36,000 added to salary in the ITR (FY 2025-26).

**Step 2 — Indian tax on the perquisite:** ₹3,36,000 × 30% = **₹1,00,800** (illustrative, before exemptions/rebates).

**Step 3 — FTC:** lower of foreign tax ₹50,400 and Indian tax ₹1,00,800 = **₹50,400**.

**Step 4 — File Form 67** (e-portal → Form 67) with country "United States," income type "salary/perquisite," foreign income ₹3,36,000, foreign tax ₹50,400, and the DTAA article — **before** the ITR due date.

**Step 5 — Claim in Schedule TR** of the ITR: foreign income and the ₹50,400 credit, against the Article invoked.

**Result:** Rohan's Indian tax on the perquisite drops from ₹1,00,800 to **₹50,400** income-tax net, PLUS 4% health & education cess (Rule 128(4) does not credit HEC — cess is charged on the pre-credit tax figure, so the true out-of-pocket is roughly ₹50,400 + ₹4,032 cess = **₹54,432**), before other credits. If he had missed the Form 67 deadline, the credit is at risk — the Department and some ITAT benches treat late Form 67 as fatal; other benches have allowed it on facts. File before the s.139(1) due date.

## The treaty-article mismatch you may face

India taxes RSU vest value as **employment income** (s.17(2)(vi), DTAA **Article 15** — Dependent Personal Services). The US broker may have reported it as a "dividend-equivalent" and withheld at **30%** (or 15% treaty dividend rate under **Article 10**) because the broker's systems do not recognise RSU compensation. The result: tax withheld on the wrong treaty article. This **mismatch must be documented** — keep the 1042-S, the W-8BEN, and the vest statement, and have your CA determine whether the full withheld amount is creditable or whether a US refund claim (Form 1040-X or a 1042-S correction) is needed. — the treatment depends on the exact facts and the DTAA article applicable to RSU compensation.

---

## Why withholding may be zero

A missing 1042-S is not a mistake — it is often the intended outcome. When you file a valid **W-8BEN** claiming the India-US DTAA, the US payer can reduce or eliminate withholding on the vest value. Many Indian residents receive their RSU vests with **zero US tax withheld** precisely because the treaty was applied correctly. The consequence in India: there is no foreign tax credit to claim, but the vest value is **still fully taxable as salary income** in India. Do not read "no withholding" as "not taxable." The perquisite enters salary, employer TDS (if any) applies, and the ITR must show the full FMV at vest.

## What if you never received a 1042-S?

If the US withheld tax but no 1042-S arrived, the credit is not lost — it is just harder to prove. Ask payroll or the broker (E*TRADE/Schwab/Fidelity) for a reprint, and check the brokerage tax-documents section for the year. As a fallback, gather the vest statement, the W-8BEN, and any payroll record of the withholding, and have your CA assess whether the credit is supportable under Rule 128. A 1042-S is the clean evidence, but the *tax paid* is the substantive requirement for the foreign tax credit — file Form 67 on the strength of the best available documentation before the ITR due date.

## Frequently Asked Questions

### 1. What is Form 1042-S in the context of RSUs?

The IRS form that reports **US-source income paid to a non-resident alien** (your RSU vest value) and the **US tax withheld**. It is the primary evidence of foreign tax paid for the Indian FTC.

### 2. What rate does the US withhold on RSU vest?

The default NRA rate is **30%**. With a valid **W-8BEN** claiming the India-US DTAA, it can be reduced or eliminated, depending on how the income is classified (compensation vs dividend-equivalent).

### 3. Where do I claim the foreign tax credit in the Indian ITR?

In **Schedule TR** (relief under s.90), backed by **Form 67** filed on the portal before the ITR due date. The credit is the lower of the foreign tax paid and the Indian tax attributable to the same income.

### 4. Can I claim credit for US state tax withheld on RSUs?

Generally **no** — only qualifying foreign *tax* attributable to the income is creditable under Rule 128; state tax is usually excluded. for your facts.

### 5. What if the US withheld 30% but India treats the income as salary?

This is the **treaty-article mismatch**: the withholding was classified (e.g., as dividend-equivalent) differently from India's salary treatment. Document the 1042-S, W-8BEN and vest statement, and confirm with your CA whether the full amount is creditable or needs a US correction/refund claim.

### 6. When must Form 67 be filed?

**On or before the ITR due date.** The Department and several ITAT decisions treat a late Form 67 as fatal to the FTC — but a number of other ITAT benches have read Rule 128(9) as directory and allowed the credit on facts. The prudent course is to file Form 67 electronically before submitting the ITR; if it's late, get CA advice on the current caselaw before assuming the credit is lost.

---

## Reconcile your 1042-S before filing

Use the **[Foreign RSU Calculator](/tools/foreign-rsu-calculator)** to convert the 1042-S figures to INR, compute the FTC cap, and prepare the numbers for Schedule TR and Form 67 — then file Form 67 first.

---

**Last verified: 2026-08-08.**  
Sources: Sections 90, 17(2)(vi) ITA 1961; Income-tax Rules, 1962 (Rule 128, Form 67); India-US DTAA (Arts. 10, 15); IRS Form 1042-S / W-8BEN.  
Reviewer: pending CA sign-off. Draft status — do not publish before CA review.: creditable US tax types; treaty-article treatment of RSU compensation.

---

## See Also

- [US Tech RSU for Indian Residents: RBI FX Rate, Schedule FA and Form 67 Foreign Tax Credit](https://www.harunraaj.com/blog/us-tech-rsu-rbi-fx-schedule-fa-form-67)
- [ESOP/RSU and Wrong ITR: Salary Perquisite + CG Forces ITR-2 and Schedule FA Checks](https://www.harunraaj.com/blog/esop-rsu-wrong-itr-form)
- [RSU Taxation in India: Vest (Salary) vs Sale (Capital Gains) Timeline with Stepped-Up Cost](https://www.harunraaj.com/blog/rsu-taxation-india-vest-sale-cost-basis)

Canonical: https://www.harunraaj.com/blog/foreign-rsu-withholding-1042s-dtaa-schedule-tr