> **Legal basis:** Section 16(2)(c), CGST Act, 2017 — Effective: ongoing. Source: CBIC Instruction 2/2023-GST (7 April 2023); SC SLP (C) No. 23993/2026 (17 July 2026); Madras HC WP No. 23402/2026 (1 July 2026); Madras HC WP (12 June 2026). Last updated: August 2026.

## The Supreme Court Has Closed This Debate

On 17 July 2026, the Supreme Court dismissed the Revenue's Special Leave Petition in **SLP (C) No. 23993/2026**, refusing to entertain the government's challenge to a pro-taxpayer High Court ruling on input tax credit. The Court's observation — "we do not find any good ground to entertain this petition" — marks the apex court's confirmation that retrospective cancellation of a supplier's GST registration is not, by itself, a valid ground to deny your Input Tax Credit (ITC).

This is the clearest signal yet that judicial doctrine on one of GST's most contested issues has solidified. If you are a recipient of goods or services, and your supplier's registration was later cancelled with retrospective effect, you are protected — provided you can demonstrate genuine supply through contemporaneous documentation.

## The Judicial Chain: Three Courts, One Answer

| Court | Case / Date | Finding |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Supreme Court | SLP (C) No. 23993/2026 (17 July 2026) | Dismissed Revenue's petition; confirmed pro-taxpayer High Court ruling; apex court refused to entertain challenge on retrospective cancellation grounds |
| Madras High Court | Clear Secured Service Private Limited v. Assistant Commissioner (ST), WP No. 23402/2026 (1 July 2026) | Set aside ITC denial where Revenue confirmed demand solely on retrospective supplier non-existence, without examining documentary proof furnished by assessee |
| Madras High Court | M/s Fathima Traders v. Deputy Commercial Tax Officer (12 June 2026) | Quashed ITC denial; held that genuine supply documentation (invoices, e-way bills, lorry receipts, payment proof) must be examined before rejection on retrospective cancellation |

> **Key point:** Courts protect bona fide recipients of goods and services with genuine documentation; retrospective supplier cancellation is one data point, not a standalone ground for demand.

## Why the Revenue's Argument Fails Under Section 16(2)(c)

The Revenue typically invokes **Section 16(2)(c) of the CGST Act, 2017**, which requires that "the tax charged in respect of such supply has been actually paid to the Government" as a condition for claiming ITC. When a supplier's registration is retrospectively cancelled, the Revenue argues the supplier could not have filed returns and paid tax — therefore Section 16(2)(c) is not satisfied.

Courts have rejected this mechanical logic. The emerging judicial consensus requires the Revenue to independently verify:

- Whether you held a valid tax invoice issued by the supplier
- Whether goods or services were actually received
- Whether you paid the invoice amount including GST (bank NEFT/RTGS proof)
- Whether e-way bills, lorry receipts, and delivery documentation were generated contemporaneously

Retroactive cancellation of the supplier's registration does not override these factual inquiries. If the supply was genuine and you paid the tax, your ITC is valid.

## CBIC Instruction 2/2023-GST Already Said This

In April 2023, the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs (CBIC) issued Instruction 2/2023-GST directing field officers **not to mechanically deny ITC solely on the basis of retrospective cancellation of a supplier's GST registration**. The Supreme Court's SLP dismissal in July 2026 places the force of apex court precedent behind this administrative instruction.

If your GST officer is issuing demands on the ground of retrospective supplier cancellation alone, reply with:

1. CBIC Instruction 2/2023-GST (7 April 2023)
2. SC SLP (C) No. 23993/2026 (17 July 2026)
3. Madras HC WP No. 23402/2026 (1 July 2026)
4. Your complete documentary package: tax invoice, e-way bill, lorry receipt, delivery challan, and bank payment proof

Do not treat the demand as final without contest.

## Protection for Genuine Buyers — Not Complicit Ones

This doctrine applies only to transactions where you genuinely received goods or services. Courts will not protect:

- **Fake invoice schemes:** Where you colluded with a non-existent supplier to manufacture fraudulent ITC
- **Non-receipt of goods or services:** Where the supply never took place
- **Forged documentation:** Where invoices, e-way bills, or lorry receipts were fabricated

Notably, the Madras High Court (13 July 2026) upheld GST registration cancellation in a separate case involving fabricated ITC documents. The protection is for the arm's-length buyer with genuine documentation, not for those who participated in tax evasion schemes.

## Practical Steps If You Receive a Demand

**Immediate actions:**

1. **Audit your purchase documentation** for all suppliers whose registrations have been cancelled — gather tax invoices, e-way bills, delivery challans, lorry receipts, and bank payment confirmations
2. **Verify your GSTR-3B filings** for the affected periods; confirm that ITC was correctly claimed and reflected in your returns
3. **On receipt of a Section 73 or 74 notice:** Do not accept the demand without a detailed reply. Provide all documentary evidence and cite the case law and CBIC instruction above
4. **If demand is confirmed at adjudication:** File an appeal immediately. This judicial trend shows a strong track record of success on appeal

**Real-world example:** A Chennai textile trader received a Section 73 demand of ₹8.2 lakh for FY 2020-21 after three suppliers' registrations were retrospectively cancelled. The trader possessed original tax invoices, e-way bills, lorry receipts, and NEFT payment confirmations for every disputed transaction. The firm's Chartered Accountant submitted a detailed reply citing Madras HC WP 23402/2026, CBIC Instruction 2/2023-GST, and the Supreme Court's SLP dismissal, with all documents annexed. The demand was dropped at the adjudication stage without further proceedings.

<!-- ORIGINAL_GRAPHIC
url: /graphics/itc-protection-genuine-supply-chain.png
alt: A flowchart showing the decision tree for ITC protection when a supplier's GST registration is retrospectively cancelled, highlighting the factors courts examine (genuine invoice, goods received, GST paid, documentary proof) versus fake supply indicators (no delivery, forged documents, collusion)
caption: Courts protect genuine buyers with complete transaction documentation; retrospective supplier cancellation alone does not deny ITC
brief: Produce a clean decision-tree flowchart in Harun Raaj & Associates brand colours (dark blue and white). Start at the top with "Supplier's GST Registration Retrospectively Cancelled". Branch into two paths: (1) "Genuine Supply — You have tax invoice, e-way bill, lorry receipt, payment proof" → outcomes: "ITC Protected" (green); (2) "Fabricated Supply — Forged documents, no delivery, collusion" → outcomes: "ITC Denied" (red). Include source citations: SC SLP 23993/2026, Madras HC WP 23402/2026, CBIC Instruction 2/2023-GST as small text at base. Do NOT show names, PAN numbers, or specific case party details. Do NOT show monetary amounts. Emphasize documentary proof and judicial protection for bona fide buyers.
-->

I'm CA Harun Raaj, Visakhapatnam. If you've received a demand based on retrospective supplier cancellation, or if you're concerned about your ITC position, reach out — we'll audit your documentation and build your response.

---

## See Also

- [Ship-to GSTIN Mandatory in e-Invoice & e-Way Bill APIs from 1 August 2026](https://www.harunraaj.com/blog/ship-to-gstin-mandatory-einvoice-eway-bill-august-2026-msu1tubx)
- [Ship-to GSTIN Mandatory in e-Invoice & e-Way Bill APIs from 1 August 2026](https://www.harunraaj.com/blog/ship-to-gstin-mandatory-einvoice-eway-bill-august-2026-msu1ts1d)
- [Ship-to GSTIN Mandatory in e-Invoice & e-Way Bill APIs from 1 August 2026](https://www.harunraaj.com/blog/ship-to-gstin-mandatory-einvoice-eway-bill-august-2026-msu1trug)

Canonical: https://www.harunraaj.com/blog/itc-not-denied-supplier-retrospective-gst-cancellation