# Can You Set Off Crypto Losses Against Salary or Stocks? Section 115BBH Rules

**Zero — you cannot set off a virtual digital asset (VDA) loss against salary, capital gains on shares, rental, or business income, and you cannot carry a VDA loss forward to any future year under s.115BBH of the Income-tax Act, 1961.** The only set-off available is VDA loss against VDA gain **in the same year** — and even that single exception is contested in current assessments. This is the most restrictive loss regime in the entire Act: no other asset class is both quarantined from other income and barred from carry-forward at the same time.

## How VDA loss rules compare with every other loss in the Act

| Income type | Set-off within same head? | Set-off against other heads? | Carry-forward? | Years |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| **VDA (s.115BBH)** | VDA loss vs VDA gain — **contested** | **No** | **No** | None |
| Speculative business | Yes (only vs speculation profit) | No — s.73(1) limits inter-head set-off | Yes (only vs speculation profit) | 4 years (s.73(2)) |
| Non-speculative business (incl. F&O) | Yes | Yes, but **not against salary** (s.71 proviso, w.e.f. AY 2025-26 per Finance (No.2) Act 2024) | Yes | 8 years |
| Short-term capital loss | Yes | Yes (vs LTCG) | Yes | 8 years |
| Long-term capital loss | Yes (vs LTCG only) | No | Yes | 8 years |
| House property loss | Yes | Yes, **capped ₹2,00,000/yr** (s.71(3A)) | Yes | 8 years |

The VDA column is the outlier. Equity losses carry forward eight years and set off against future gains; business losses carry forward four to eight years; even speculative losses get four. A VDA loss is extinguished in the assessment year it arises — unless you happen to have a VDA gain in the same year to absorb it.

## The two statutory bars

Section 115BBH(2) creates the quarantine:

- **s.115BBH(2)(b)** — "the loss, if any, from the transfer of a virtual digital asset, if it is a loss computed under clause (a), **shall not be set off against the income computed under any other provision of this Act**." Salary, stocks, rent, business — none can absorb a VDA loss.
- **No carry-forward under s.74.** Section 74 (capital loss carry-forward) applies to capital gains, not to the special VDA regime. There is no separate carry-forward provision for VDA losses, so a loss that cannot be set off in-year is simply gone.

The wording "against the income computed under any other provision" is what makes the intra-VDA netting question genuinely open — see below.

## The contested point: can a BTC loss net an ETH gain?

**Unsettled.** Whether a loss on one VDA can be set off against a gain on another VDA *in the same year* is not settled:

- **Argument for netting:** s.115BBH(2)(b) bars set-off against income "under any other provision." A loss and a gain *both* computed under s.115BBH are arguably within the same provision, so netting is permitted. The Schedule VDA in the ITR and most tax software compute a net VDA figure for the year.
- **Argument against:** some Assessing Officers read the bar literally and reject even intra-VDA netting, treating each transfer as its own chargeable event.

The position is being tested in AY 2022-23 and AY 2023-24 assessments. Until a court settles it, do **not** file a net figure without your CA confirming the current department position. The difference is material: ₹4 lakh of BTC loss can erase ₹4 lakh of ETH gain — a ₹1,24,800 swing at 31.2% — or it cannot.

## Worked example: Meera, BTC loss, ETH gain, equity LTCG

**Persona:** Meera, salaried employee, FY 2025-26 (AY 2026-27). Three events in the year:

- Sells Bitcoin (BTC) — loss **₹4,00,000**
- Sells Ethereum (ETH) — gain **₹1,50,000**
- Sells listed equity — long-term gain **₹2,00,000** (taxable 12.5% u/s 112A)
- Salary ₹20,00,000 (new regime)

**Step 1 — What the loss CANNOT do.**

- ❌ Cannot set off against salary income (₹20L taxed at slab).
- ❌ Cannot set off against the ₹2,00,000 equity LTCG (different provision — s.112A).
- ❌ Cannot carry forward to AY 2027-28.

**Step 2 — What it CAN do (contested).** Net BTC loss against ETH gain within the VDA block: ₹4,00,000 − ₹1,50,000 = **₹2,50,000 net VDA loss**. Under the netting interpretation, VDA tax = ₹0, and the remaining ₹2,50,000 loss is extinguished. Under the no-netting interpretation, the ETH gain of ₹1,50,000 is taxed at **₹46,800** (31.2%) and the ₹4,00,000 loss is entirely extinguished.

**Step 3 — The equity gain is unaffected either way.**

- Equity LTCG ₹2,00,000 × 12.5% = ₹25,000 (no indexation; s.112A) — this tax is payable regardless of the crypto position.

The two interpretations produce a ₹46,800 difference in Meera's VDA tax. That single line is why the intra-VDA netting question decides whether her year's return is correct.

## What this means for your strategy

1. **Don't "harvest" VDA losses to offset other income** — the Act forbids it. A loss-maker who also has stock gains gets no cross-set-off.
2. **Realise VDA losses in a year you have VDA gains**, if the netting position holds — that is the only year a loss has value.
3. **Don't carry a losing position into a fresh year hoping the loss survives** — it cannot. Each year's VDA block stands alone.
4. **Keep per-transaction records** even on loss trades — the department's SFT data shows gross sale consideration, and your declared loss must reconcile.

> **Changed FY 2025-26:** No change in the statute — s.115BBH(2) has read the same since AY 2023-24. What changed is enforcement reality: exchange SFT/AIS data now flows to most filers, so under-declared VDA gains and inflated loss claims are the specific items the reconciliation engine flags. A loss claimed on Schedule VDA that cannot be explained against the exchange data is a 143(1) adjustment waiting to happen.

## Frequently asked questions

### 1. Can I set off a crypto loss against my salary?
**No.** s.115BBH(2)(b) prohibits set-off of VDA losses against income computed under any other provision of the Act, and salary is computed under a different provision.

### 2. Can I set off a crypto loss against stock gains?
**No.** Equity long-term gains are charged under s.112A; a VDA loss cannot reduce them. They are different provisions, and the bar in s.115BBH(2)(b) applies.

### 3. Can I set off one crypto loss against another crypto gain?
**Possibly.** Intra-VDA netting in the same year is contested between practitioners and some Assessing Officers. It is not safe to assume until the department position is confirmed for your case.

### 4. Can I carry a crypto loss forward to next year?
**No.** There is no carry-forward provision for VDA losses; s.74 does not apply. The loss is extinguished in the year it arises.

### 5. How is a VDA loss different from an F&O loss?
**F&O losses set off against other income (but not against salary since AY 2025-26 — s.71 proviso, FA(No.2) 2024) and carry forward eight years.** VDA losses do neither. F&O is non-speculative business income; VDA is a quarantined special rate.

### 6. What if my loss is bigger than all my gains in a year?
**The excess is lost.** Any VDA loss not absorbed by VDA gain in the same year is extinguished permanently. Plan disposals accordingly.

### 7. Where do I report the loss?
**Schedule VDA in ITR-2/ITR-3**, transaction-by-transaction, with the loss figure flagged only if your CA confirms intra-VDA netting is being accepted for your assessment year.

---

**Last verified:** 2026-08-08 (FY 2025-26 / AY 2026-27)

**Sources:** s.115BBH(2)(a)–(b), Income-tax Act, 1961; s.74 (capital-loss carry-forward — not applicable to VDA); s.71, s.71(3A) (set-off framework); s.112A (equity LTCG); s.115BBE (analogous special-rate quarantine). The intra-VDA netting position is contested. For a VDA computation before filing, use the [Crypto VDA Tax Calculator](/tools/crypto-vda-tax-calculator) or book a consultation at harunraaj.com.

---

## See Also

- [Crypto Tax in India: 30% + 4% Cess on VDA Gains — What Salaried Employees Owe](https://www.harunraaj.com/blog/crypto-tax-india-30-percent-vda-salaried)
- [TDS u/s 194S on Crypto: Reconcile Exchange 194S with Form 26AS Before Filing](https://www.harunraaj.com/blog/crypto-tds-194s-26as-reconciliation)
- [Wrong Schedule for Crypto (Other Sources vs VDA): Common ITR Mistakes and 139(9) Risk](https://www.harunraaj.com/blog/crypto-wrong-schedule-itr-139-9)

Canonical: https://www.harunraaj.com/blog/vda-loss-set-off-section-115bbh