Harun Raaj & AssociatesHarun Raaj & Associates
fdi-setup

"We have no Chinese investors": what Press Note 3's beneficial ownership test actually requires

Press Note 3 catches you through your investors' investors. Here is the beneficial ownership test, the 2026 safe harbour, and how to stay on automatic route.

HR

Harun Raaj

Chartered Accountant · Harun Raaj & Associates

The sentence that derails more India entries than any other is spoken with complete confidence in a diligence call: "We're a Delaware company, our investors are US and European funds, none of this land border stuff applies to us." Three weeks later the authorised dealer bank refuses to process the FC-GPR, because one of those funds has a Cayman feeder vehicle with limited partners in Hong Kong, and nobody can produce a clean beneficial ownership chart. The money is already in the Indian company's account. That is the worst possible sequence, and it is entirely avoidable if you run the test before you wire.

What the regulation actually says

Press Note 3 (2020 Series), issued by the Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade on 17 April 2020, amended paragraph 3.1.1 of the Consolidated FDI Policy. The change was given legal force under the Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 through the Foreign Exchange Management (Non-debt Instruments) Amendment Rules, 2020, which amended Rule 6 of the NDI Rules, 2019.

The operative rule has two limbs, and the second limb is the one foreign founders miss.

Limb one — the entity test. An entity of a country which shares a land border with India can invest in an Indian company only under the government approval route. The land border countries are China, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Nepal, Myanmar, Bhutan and Afghanistan. This limb is straightforward: if the investing entity is incorporated in one of those seven countries, government approval is mandatory regardless of sector, regardless of size, regardless of whether the sector otherwise sits on the automatic route.

Limb two — the beneficial ownership test. An entity is equally caught where the beneficial owner of the investment is situated in, or is a citizen of, any of those countries. This applies even if the investing entity itself is incorporated in Singapore, Delaware, Luxembourg or anywhere else. Nationality of the vehicle is irrelevant. What matters is who sits behind it.

There is a separate and stricter position for citizens and entities of Pakistan and Bangladesh, who face additional sectoral prohibitions — Pakistani investors cannot invest at all in defence, space, atomic energy, or sectors otherwise prohibited to foreign investment, even with approval.

The persistent difficulty since 2020 has been that Press Note 3 never defined "beneficial owner" and never specified a shareholding threshold. Indian law contains at least two competing definitions: the significant beneficial ownership regime under Section 90 of the Companies Act, 2013 read with the SBO Rules uses a 10% test, while the Prevention of Money Laundering Act framework generally uses 25% for companies. Because the FDI policy adopted neither, authorised dealer banks and company secretaries have applied the most conservative reading available to them, which in practice has meant treating any traceable land-border interest, however small, as a trigger for the approval route.

The 2026 development. On 15 March 2026, DPIIT issued Press Note 2 (2026 Series), formalising a Union Cabinet decision of 10 March 2026 and introducing a safe harbour for minority, passive positions with an indirect land-border nexus. As reported, the safe harbour permits an investment to proceed on the automatic route where aggregate beneficial ownership attributable to land-border-country nationals or entities is 10% or below and the land-border investor holds no control rights. DPIIT followed this with a revised Standard Operating Procedure on 4 May 2026 governing how government-route proposals are processed.

Two cautions before you rely on this. First, both conditions are cumulative — a 4% economic interest coupled with a board nomination right, veto over reserved matters, or an affirmative-vote package will not qualify, because the investor holds control rights. Second, always read the operative Press Note 2 text on the DPIIT website against your own cap table rather than relying on a summary, including this one. The safe harbour is narrow and the drafting matters.

Practical implications: what happens if you get this wrong

Getting Press Note 3 wrong is not a paperwork problem. It is a contravention of FEMA, and it has three distinct consequences that arrive in sequence.

The transaction stalls at the bank. Every inbound equity investment must be reported to the Reserve Bank of India in Form FC-GPR through the FIRMS portal, filed by the Indian investee company within 30 days of allotment, routed through its authorised dealer bank. The AD bank is the gatekeeper. If it cannot satisfy itself on the land-border position, it will not process the filing. Your money is in India, your shares are unallotted or allotted without valid reporting, and you have no clean route out.

Compounding under Section 13. Receiving foreign investment on the automatic route where government approval was required is a contravention under FEMA. The remedy is a compounding application to the RBI under Section 15, disclosing the contravention voluntarily and paying a compounding amount calculated on the sum involved and the delay. Compounding is available and routinely granted, but it is public, it takes months, and the application itself becomes a permanent part of your regulatory record.

Exit becomes the real cost. The damage surfaces at the next round or at trade sale. An acquirer's diligence will find an unresolved land-border question, and it will either price it in, escrow against it, or make the deal conditional on approval being obtained retrospectively. Government-route approval applications routinely run several months. A four-month regulatory hold on a signed term sheet is where the commercial loss actually lands.

Step-by-step: what to do

  • Build a full beneficial ownership chart before you sign anything. Trace every layer to natural persons — not to the first fund, not to the first holding company. For each ultimate beneficial owner, record citizenship and country of residence. Feeder vehicles, nominee arrangements and trust structures must be looked through. This is the document your Indian counsel and your AD bank will ask for first.
  • Test each land-border interest against both safe harbour conditions. Aggregate all land-border-attributable beneficial ownership; is the total 10% or below? Separately, does any land-border-linked holder have control rights — board seats, nomination rights, veto or reserved-matter consent, affirmative vote items, or negative control through a shareholders' agreement? Both answers must be favourable. If either fails, you are on the government approval route.
  • If you are on the approval route, file through the National Single Window System. FDI applications requiring government approval are made through the NSWS portal (formerly the Foreign Investment Facilitation Portal), which routes the application to the administrative ministry for your sector. Follow the current SOP, revised 4 May 2026, on documentation and processing steps. Budget realistically: several months, with clarification rounds.
  • Obtain a valuation report before allotment. Shares issued to a non-resident must be priced at or above fair value, determined by any internationally accepted pricing methodology on an arm's length basis, certified by a SEBI-registered merchant banker or a practising chartered accountant. Pricing below fair value is an independent FEMA contravention, separate from any land-border issue.
  • File Form FC-GPR within 30 days of allotment. Filed by the Indian company on the FIRMS portal through its AD bank, with the valuation certificate, the company secretary's certificate and the KYC report on the remitter. Note that the clock runs from allotment, not from receipt of funds — companies that sit on inward remittance for weeks before allotting are creating a second, independent delay problem.
  • File Form FC-TRS for any subsequent transfer. Where shares later move between a resident and a non-resident — including a secondary sale to a new investor — Form FC-TRS is required within 60 days of transfer or receipt of consideration, whichever is earlier. Run the land-border test again on the incoming transferee. Press Note 3 applies to transfers, not only to fresh issues, and this is the point at which otherwise clean companies acquire a problem.
  • Re-run the test at every round. Beneficial ownership is not a one-time diagnostic. A new limited partner in one of your existing funds can change your position without any action by you or by the Indian company. Make the land-border representation a standing warranty in your subscription documents.

FAQ

Does Press Note 3 apply if my Singapore holding company has a single Chinese shareholder holding 3%?
Under the pre-2026 position, conservative practice treated any traceable land-border interest as a trigger. Following Press Note 2 (2026 Series), a 3% aggregate interest can fall within the safe harbour and proceed on the automatic route — but only if that shareholder holds no control rights of any kind. If they have a board nomination right or veto over reserved matters, the safe harbour does not apply and government approval is required.

Is Hong Kong treated as China for this test?
Market practice, and the position AD banks generally take, is to treat Hong Kong SAR interests as attributable to China for Press Note 3 purposes. Do not assume a Hong Kong entity or resident sits outside the rule. Disclose it, chart it, and get a written view from Indian counsel before you rely on the automatic route.

We already invested without approval. What now?
Do not wait for the AD bank or RBI to raise it. Instruct Indian counsel to prepare a voluntary compounding application to the RBI under Section 15 of FEMA, disclosing the contravention, and in parallel assess whether the position now qualifies under the 2026 safe harbour — if it does, your exposure may be limited to reporting delays rather than a route breach. Voluntary disclosure materially improves the outcome.

---

Planning India entry? Start with a free structure review at makeitlegit.in

Need help with this?

Our team handles the paperwork. You focus on your business.