Closing a Seed Round Without Proper Paperwork: What Companies Act 2013 and FEMA Actually Require

Closing a Seed Round Without Proper Paperwork: What Companies Act 2013 and FEMA Actually Require

A founder closes a ₹1 crore seed round from three angel investors in November, celebrates with the team, and moves on to building the product. Eight months later, an institutional investor conducting due diligence for a Series A asks for the SHA, the PAS-3, and the board resolution authorising the allotment. The founder produces a WhatsApp agreement and a bank transfer receipt. The Series A falls apart.

This is not a hypothetical. It is one of the most common — and most avoidable — ways that Indian startups kill their fundraising momentum. The Companies Act 2013, FEMA 1999, and the Foreign Exchange Management (Non-Debt Instruments) Rules, 2019 impose a specific sequence of documents, resolutions, and regulatory filings on every seed round. Missing any one of them creates a defect that is expensive to cure retroactively and sometimes cannot be cured at all.

This article walks through every document that is legally required when a private company raises a seed round from resident or foreign investors, with the exact section numbers, form names, and deadlines.

---

What the Law Actually Requires

1. The Board Resolution — Section 179(3)(c), Companies Act 2013

Before a single rupee is received, the board of directors must pass a resolution authorising the issuance of shares or instruments. This is not optional courtesy. Section 179(3)(c) of the Companies Act 2013 requires the board to approve the issue of securities by passing a resolution at a duly convened board meeting.

The resolution must state:

• The number of shares (or CCPS units) being issued


• The issue price per share (or conversion ratio for CCPS)


• The name and particulars of each allottee


• The basis on which the price was determined (for equity, this should reference a valuation report or a DCF method under Rule 11UA if CCPS is involved)


• Authority granted to a director or company secretary to file necessary forms with the Registrar of Companies (ROC)

The board meeting must be called with at least seven days' notice under Section 173, must meet quorum (one-third of total directors or two directors, whichever is higher, per Section 174), and the minutes must be signed and entered in the minutes book within thirty days under Section 118.

Common mistake: Founders pass a resolution over email or WhatsApp and never formalise it into signed physical or digital minutes. This means there is no legally valid board authorisation, and the entire allotment is voidable.

2. Private Placement and Section 42 — The Offer Letter (PAS-4) and Application Form

If you are raising from more than two investors at the seed stage, the Companies Act almost certainly classifies the issuance as a "private placement" under Section 42. Private placement has a very specific legal definition: any offer or invitation to subscribe to securities to a select group of persons (not exceeding 200 in a financial year under Section 42(2)).

What Section 42 requires:

• A Private Placement Offer cum Application Letter in Form PAS-4, which must be approved by the board before being sent to investors


• Applications from each investor in a prescribed form


• Receipt of application money in a separate bank account — not the company's current account — before allotment


• Allotment must be made within 60 days of receipt of application money (Section 42(6)); if not made within 60 days, the amount must be refunded within 15 days thereafter


• Filing of Form PAS-3 with the Registrar of Companies within 15 days of allotment (Section 42(9))

Penalty for non-compliance with Section 42: Under Section 42(10), failure to file PAS-3 within 15 days attracts a fine of ₹1,000 per day of default, subject to a maximum of ₹25 lakh on the company and ₹1 lakh per day (up to ₹5 lakh) on the defaulting officer. More critically, MCA21 v3 now cross-validates PAS-3 against the share capital in MGT-7A and AOC-4. If a seed allotment was never filed on PAS-3, the discrepancy will show up in the annual filing and trigger a scrutiny notice automatically.

3. CCPS vs. Equity Shares — Why This Choice Matters Legally

Most seed investors in India receive Compulsorily Convertible Preference Shares (CCPS) rather than equity. This is not just a preference — it has significant legal implications.

CCPS is governed by Section 43 and Section 55 of the Companies Act 2013:

• Section 43 permits a company to issue preference shares


• Section 55 makes it mandatory that preference shares either be redeemable or compulsorily convertible — a company cannot issue perpetual preference shares


• The conversion ratio, conversion triggers, and timeline must be specified in the Articles of Association (AoA) before CCPS is issued

If your AoA does not permit CCPS issuance, you cannot issue CCPS. This is the second most common seed-round defect: founders issue CCPS without first checking whether the AoA allows it. Amending the AoA requires a special resolution under Section 14, filing Form MGT-14 with the ROC within 30 days of passing the resolution (Section 117(3)(a)), and payment of stamp duty.

CCPS vs. equity at seed stage — the practical considerations:

• CCPS gives investors a liquidation preference and conversion rights without immediately diluting the cap table in equity terms


• For foreign investors, CCPS is classified as FDI under the Foreign Exchange Management (Non-Debt Instruments) Rules 2019 and must be reported on Form FC-GPR within 30 days of allotment


• Equity issued to foreign investors at this stage triggers the same FC-GPR obligation


• A valuation report from a SEBI-registered Merchant Banker or a Registered Valuer is mandatory for CCPS issued to foreign investors to establish the "fair market value" floor under FEMA pricing guidelines (Rule 21 of NDI Rules 2019)

4. The Shareholders' Agreement (SHA) — Not a Companies Act Form, But Legally Critical

The SHA is a private contract between the company, its founders, and investors. It is not filed with the ROC and is not a statutory document. However, it is the document that governs investor rights, founder obligations, and exit mechanics.

What a seed-stage SHA must include:

• Information rights: Quarterly financials, annual audited accounts, access to board minutes


• Anti-dilution provisions: Weighted average or full ratchet — most Indian seed SHAs use broad-based weighted average


• Right of First Refusal (ROFR): Existing investors' right to match any third-party offer before a founder sells shares


• Tag-along rights: Investors' right to participate in any sale of shares by founders on the same terms


• Drag-along rights: Majority shareholders' right to compel minority holders to sell in an M&A transaction


• Founder vesting: Reverse vesting schedule — typically 4 years with a 1-year cliff — to protect investors if a co-founder exits early


• Board composition: Who controls board seats, how many seats investors get, and observer rights


• Affirmative vote matters: Decisions that require investor consent (new share issuance, changes to business, capex above a threshold, etc.)

Companies Act alignment: The SHA is enforceable as a private contract, but provisions that conflict with the Companies Act or the AoA are unenforceable. For example, an SHA clause that allows a shareholder to appoint a director without a board or shareholder resolution cannot override Section 152. Founders often discover this mismatch only at Series A, when lawyers doing due diligence flag contradictions between the SHA and the AoA.

The fix is to align the AoA with the SHA at the time of signing — an often-skipped step that requires a special resolution and MGT-14 filing.

5. Share Subscription and Purchase Agreement (SSPA / SPA)

The SSPA documents the terms on which investors subscribe to shares or CCPS. It is distinct from the SHA (which governs ongoing rights) and is the document that actually transfers the legal obligation to pay and the obligation to allot.

A well-drafted SSPA at seed stage includes:

• Representations and warranties by the company and founders (clean title to IP, no undisclosed liabilities, no ongoing litigation)


• Conditions precedent to closing (board resolution, amended AoA if needed, KYC documents)


• Use of proceeds


• Closing mechanics and timeline

The SSPA must be stamped. Stamp duty on a share subscription agreement varies by state — in Maharashtra it is 0.1% of the transaction value, in Karnataka it can be up to 0.5%. An unstamped SSPA is inadmissible as evidence in court and creates a document defect that due diligence will flag.

---

Practical Implications: What Happens When This Is Ignored

• Series A due diligence failure: The most common consequence. Institutional investors conduct legal DD before term sheet signing. Missing PAS-3, an unamended AoA, or an unstamped SHA are standard deal-killers.
• MCA21 v3 auto-flag: The new MCA21 v3 portal cross-validates your share capital declared in MGT-7A with PAS-3 filings. If you allotted shares but never filed PAS-3, your annual return will show a mismatch. This triggers a compliance notice from the ROC without any human intervention.
• FEMA penalty for missed FC-GPR: If any seed investor is a foreign national, NRI (investing on a non-repatriation basis through NRO), or foreign entity, missing the 30-day FC-GPR window under FEMA attracts a Late Submission Fee calculated at 0.05% of the outstanding amount per day for delays up to three years. Compounding under Section 15 FEMA is the only cure, and the compounding fee itself can be substantial.
• Tax exposure on CCPS issued at wrong price: Post-Finance Act 2024, angel tax under Section 56(2)(viib) has been abolished for DPIIT-registered startups. But for non-registered companies, CCPS issued at a value above Fair Market Value can still attract income tax in the investor's hands. And if issued at below FMV to founders (in a secondary transaction), Section 56(2)(x) applies to the buyer.
• Founder liability: Section 447 of the Companies Act 2013 classifies fraudulent conduct in share allotments as a serious offence with imprisonment of up to 10 years. While enforcement at seed stage is rare, it becomes relevant if the company later faces NCLT proceedings or investor disputes.

---

Step-by-Step: What to Do Before Closing a Seed Round

• Verify AoA permits CCPS (if you are issuing CCPS). If not, pass a special resolution amending the AoA under Section 14 and file Form MGT-14 within 30 days.
• Get a valuation report from a SEBI-registered Merchant Banker or Registered Valuer (under Companies (Registered Valuers and Valuation) Rules 2017). Use DCF or NAV method. This establishes the per-share price and protects you from Section 56(2)(viib) exposure for any non-DPIIT-registered entities.
• Pass a board resolution under Section 179(3)(c) at a properly constituted meeting with seven days' notice, quorum, and signed minutes entered within 30 days.
• Draft and execute the SSPA and SHA. Get both stamped. Align the AoA with SHA provisions.
• Issue Form PAS-4 (Private Placement Offer Letter) to each investor individually. Collect signed application forms.
• Open a separate bank account to receive application money. Do not mix with operating funds.
• Complete allotment within 60 days of receiving application money. Pass the allotment board resolution.
• File Form PAS-3 with the ROC within 15 days of allotment. Attach the list of allottees, board resolution, and consent of allottees.
• If any investor is foreign: File Form FC-GPR with the Authorised Dealer (AD) bank within 30 days of allotment. Attach the SSPA, board resolution, valuation report, and KYC documents.
• Issue share certificates within 60 days of allotment (Section 56(4)(b)) or CCPS certificates within the same window.
• Update statutory registers: Register of Members (Section 88), Register of Significant Beneficial Owners (if any investor holds >10% beneficial interest — Form BEN-2 under Section 90), and Register of Contracts.

---

FAQ

Q: Can we close the seed round first and sort out the paperwork later?
A: No. The allotment is legally invalid without prior board authorisation, a PAS-4 offer letter, and a proper application form. Retroactive "paperwork" is fabrication, not compliance, and creates a larger problem than delaying the close by one week.

Q: Does the SHA need to be registered anywhere?
A: The SHA is a private contract and is not registered with any regulator. However, it must be stamped in the state where it is executed. Unstamped agreements are inadmissible as evidence in Indian courts.

Q: What is the difference between PAS-3 and MGT-14?
A: PAS-3 is the Return of Allotment filed when shares or CCPS are allotted (within 15 days of allotment under Section 42(9)). MGT-14 is filed when a special or ordinary resolution is passed at a shareholder meeting — for example, when the AoA is amended or when a preferential allotment under Section 62(1)(c) is authorised. Both may be required in a seed round depending on the structure.

Q: If we have only two investors, do Section 42 private placement rules apply?
A: Section 42 applies to any offer to a "select group of persons." Even two investors trigger the requirements for a board-approved PAS-4, separate bank account, and PAS-3 filing. There is no minimum-investor threshold below which private placement rules are waived. The only alternative is a rights issue under Section 62(1)(a), which is rarely used at seed stage because it requires offering shares pro-rata to existing shareholders first.

---

Closing Thought

The CCFS-2026 scheme (General Circular 01/2026) — which allowed filing of pending statutory documents at reduced fees — closes on 15 July 2026. If your company has outstanding PAS-3 or MGT-14 filings from past allotments, you have one week to regularise them at concessionary rates. After 15 July, normal additional fees apply, which compound daily.

Seed round compliance is not bureaucracy for its own sake. Every document in this checklist is a legal prerequisite for the allotment to be valid, for investor rights to be enforceable, and for your Series A due diligence to close in weeks rather than months.

For a compliance audit of your company, visit pvtltd.co

Need help with this?

Our team handles the paperwork. You focus on your business.