Harun Raaj & AssociatesHarun Raaj & Associates
direct-tax

Your clinic just crossed ₹75 lakh. Here is everything that changes

HR

Harun Raaj

Chartered Accountant · Harun Raaj & Associates

For years your tax life fit in one line: gross receipts × 50%, ITR-4, done. Section 44ADA made a growing practice almost administratively invisible. The day your receipts cross ₹75 lakh, that entire regime switches off at once — and most doctors discover it in March, when the options have already narrowed.

Here is the full map: the two thresholds, what dies at each one, and the checklist for the transition year.

The two thresholds — ₹50 lakh and ₹75 lakh

Section 44ADA lets a notified professional (medicine is one, under s.44AA(1)) declare 50% of gross receipts as presumptive profit — or more, if the actual profit is more — with no books under s.44AA and no audit under s.44AB.

The basic eligibility ceiling is ₹50 lakh of gross receipts. The Finance Act 2023 added a proviso raising it to ₹75 lakh — but only if cash receipts are 5% or less of total receipts (put positively: at least 95% digital — bank, UPI, cards, cheques). Miss the 95% test in a year where receipts are between ₹50L and ₹75L, and you are outside 44ADA for that year: books plus s.44AB audit.

Two structural notes doctors regularly get wrong:

  • The 95% test is receipts-based, not patient-based. One ₹4 lakh cash surgery in a ₹70 lakh year can single-handedly breach 5%.
  • Only individuals and HUFs get the ₹75 lakh proviso — and LLPs were never eligible for s.44ADA at any threshold.

What switches off above ₹75 lakh

Presumptive assessment. Above ₹75 lakh there is no 44ADA at any digital percentage. You maintain books of account under s.44AA and get them audited under s.44AB — Form 3CB-3CD through a CA, due 30 September (one month before your ITR due date of 31 October for audit cases).

The one-instalment advance-tax privilege. Under the proviso to s.211(1)(b), a 44ADA assessee pays all advance tax by 15 March. Outside 44ADA you are back to the four-instalment calendar — 15 June, 15 September, 15 December, 15 March — with s.234C interest per deferred instalment.

ITR-4. Your form becomes ITR-3, with full P&L and balance-sheet schedules. Filing ITR-4 out of habit invites a defective-return notice under s.139(9).

The penalty for ignoring all this is s.271B: 0.5% of gross receipts for failure to get audited, capped at ₹1.5 lakh — plus the interest that follows recomputed income.

What switches on — the part nobody tells you

Presumptive taxation was convenient, but it taxed you on a deemed 50% margin whether or not your real margin was lower. Books cut both ways:

  • Real expenses become claimable: staff salaries, rent, consumables, indemnity insurance, journal subscriptions — deductible under s.37(1) if incurred wholly for the profession.
  • Depreciation under s.32: that ₹40 lakh ultrasound machine now depreciates against income; medical equipment generally sits in the 15% plant-and-machinery block. Under 44ADA, depreciation was deemed already allowed — you got no separate benefit.
  • A clinic with heavy equipment and real rent can have a true margin well below 50%. For many practices the audit year is the year the effective tax rate falls. Run the comparison before you resent the compliance.

Watch the cash-discipline sections that now bite line-by-line: expenses above ₹10,000 paid in cash are disallowed under s.40A(3), and accepting ₹2 lakh or more in cash from a patient in a single transaction breaches s.269ST (penalty under s.271DA: the entire amount).

The transition-year checklist

  • Track the 95% digital ratio monthly from April — not in March. If a large cash receipt is unavoidable, know what it does to the ratio before accepting it.
  • Open the books on 1 April of the crossing year: a case register, expense ledger and reconciled bank statements. Reconstructing a year in February is what audit qualifications are made of.
  • Fix asset values: for equipment bought during 44ADA years, written-down values are computed as if depreciation had been allowed in those years — get this schedule right once, at entry.
  • Recompute advance tax on the four-instalment calendar from the first year outside 44ADA.
  • Book the auditor before December. A 30 September deadline met in September is a myth you only believe once.
  • Ask the entity question now: at hospital scale, proprietorship vs LLP vs Pvt Ltd changes your rate, your audit burden and your family's participation. That decision is better made a year early than a day late.

---

Crossing the threshold this year? Harun Raaj & Associates, Visakhapatnam builds the transition plan — books from 1 April, the 44ADA-vs-books comparison, the audit calendar, and the entity memo — before the year closes around you.

See Also

Frequently Asked Questions

1. My receipts are ₹68 lakh, all digital. Do I need an audit?

No — the proviso to s.44ADA covers you up to ₹75 lakh provided cash receipts are 5% or less of total receipts. Declare 50% (or your higher actual profit) and file ITR-4. Watch the ratio monthly.

2. Receipts ₹68 lakh, but ₹6 lakh came in cash. Now?

Cash is 8.8% — the proviso fails. For that year you are outside 44ADA: books under s.44AA, audit under s.44AB, ITR-3.

3. Is the audit itself expensive?

The real cost is not the audit fee — it is entering audit season with no books. With a live case register and reconciled bank account, a clinic audit is routine. Without them it is an archaeology project billed by the hour.

4. Can I come back to 44ADA if receipts fall below the limit again?

Yes. s.44ADA has no lock-in equivalent to s.44AD(4)'s five-year bar on businesses. Eligibility is tested year by year — if next year's receipts are back within the ceiling (with the digital test met for the ₹50–75L band), you can opt in again.

5. Should I convert to an LLP to "simplify"?

An LLP cannot use 44ADA at all and needs a s.44AB audit past ₹50 lakh regardless of digital mix. Convert for structural reasons — partners, liability, succession — never for presumptive taxation, which conversion destroys.

Related Services

Based on this article's category and vertical tag, these services are the most relevant next steps.

Go deeper with our hub guides

Statute-cited, section-by-section guides covering the same ground this article does.

Need help with this?

Our team handles the paperwork. You focus on your business.